Which colony was settled by many Quakers and initially split due to confusing property lines?

The colony that was settled by many Quakers and initially faced issues with confusing property lines is New Jersey. Quakers, seeking religious freedom and a place to establish their own communities, were significant settlers in the region. New Jersey was initially part of the larger New York colony, but it was divided into East and West Jersey to accommodate different groups of settlers, including the Quakers, who preferred to settle in areas that welcomed their beliefs.

The confusion over property lines stemmed from the colonial divisions that occurred, leading to disputes between landowners — including those of Quaker descent — and contributing to the eventual splitting of the colony. This fragmentation represented the challenges of governance and land claim that were common in early colonial America, particularly in areas where multiple groups wanted to establish their presence.

While Rhode Island was known for its diverse population and religious toleration, and Delaware was originally part of Pennsylvania and had its own unique development, the key association of Quakers and the initial division of property line disputes distinctly identifies New Jersey as the correct answer. Pennsylvania, also settled by many Quakers, primarily focused on those exact settlers' experiences and governance structures rather than property line issues as a primary identifier.